Saturation-functions models in CO2-brine system: A comparative study
Abstract view|57|times PDF download|24|times
Abstract
CO2 injections into deep saline aquifers create a multiphase flow system within the porous media. In this context, relative permeability and capillary pressure, as saturation functions, are key parameters that control flow dynamics, simulation accuracy, and operational decisions. Since various models have been proposed for the saturation functions, this study aims to assess the existing models and investigate which model performs best under different circumstances. To this end, we first gathered a comprehensive data set to evaluate the existing models. Following that, the nonlinear fitting of experimental data was used to obtain the parameters of each model. Finally, the root-mean-square error and correlation coefficients were used to assess the accuracy of the fit. Based on the results of capillary pressure analysis, the models can be classified into two main categories. The first category includes models with power-law behavior suitable for homogeneous formations (single curvature), such as Brooks-Corey, Li-Horne, Lambda, Thomeer, Leverett J-function, and modified J-function models. The second category includes Van Genuchten, Kosugi, Skelt-Harison, Johnson, and Jing-Van Wunnik, which can be applied to homogeneous and heterogeneous formations (capture more than one curvature). Regarding relative permeability, the L.E.T., Chierici, Van Genuchten, and Corey models exhibit comparable performance across all scenarios. Corey offers simplicity with minimal parameters, while Van Genuchten provides more adaptability for complex data sets with more physically based parameters.
Document Type: Original article
Cited as: Faramarzi, M., Tabatabaei, S. M., Sedaee, B., Attari, N., Panahi, S. A. Saturation-functions models in CO2-brine system: A comparative study. Capillarity, 2025, 14(2): 35-52. https://doi.org/10.46690/capi.2025.02.01
Keywords
Full Text:
PDFReferences
Abdollahian, A., Tadayoni, M., Junin, R. B. A new approach to reduce uncertainty in reservoir characterization using saturation height modeling, Mesaverde tight gas sandstones, western US basins. Journal of Petroleum Exploration and Production Technology, 2019, 9(3): 1953-1961.
Abdoulghafour, H., Sarmadivaleh, M., Hauge, L. P., et al. Capillary pressure characteristics of CO2-brine-sandstone systems. International Journal of Greenhouse Gas Control, 2020, 94: 102876.
Akbarabadi, M., Piri, M. Relative permeability hysteresis and capillary trapping characteristics of supercritical CO2/brine systems: An experimental study at reservoir conditions. Advances in Water Resources, 2013, 52: 190-206.
Alizadeh, A. H., Piri, M. Three-phase flow in porous media: A review of experimental studies on relative permeability. Reviews of Geophysics, 2014, 52(3): 468-521.
Al-Bulushi, N., King, P. R., Blunt, M. J., et al. Development of artificial neural network models for predicting water saturation and fluid distribution. Journal of Petroleum Science and Engineering, 2009, 68(3-4): 197-208.
Al-Bulushi, N., Kraishan, G., Hursan, G. Capillary pressure corrections, quality control and curve fitting workflow. Paper IPTC 19514 Presented at the International Petroleum Technology Conference, Beijing, China, 26-28 March, 2019.
Al-Menhali, A., Niu, B., Krevor, S. Capillarity and wetting of carbon dioxide and brine during drainage in Berea sandstone at reservoir conditions. Water Resources Research, 2015, 51(10): 7895-7914.
Al Waili, I. H. Developing generalised capillary pressure curves and saturation height function for Shuaiba carbonate reservoirs in field A. Paper SPE 136191 Presented at the SPE Annual Technical Conference and Exhibition, New Orleans, Louisiana, 4-7 October, 2009.
Bachu, S., Bennion, B. Effects of in-situ conditions on relative permeability characteristics of CO2-brine systems. Environmental Geology, 54(8): 1707-1722, 2008.
Bakhshian, S., Hosseini, S. A. Pore-scale analysis of supercritical CO2-brine immiscible displacement under fractional-wettability conditions. Advances in Water Resources, 2019, 126: 96-107.
Bakhshian, S., Hosseini, S. A., Lake, L. W. CO2-brine relative permeability and capillary pressure of Tuscaloosa sandstone: Effect of anisotropy. Advances in Water Resources, 2020, 135: 103464.
Behrenbruch, P., Huu, M. T., Hoang, T. G., et al. Modelling of drainage capillary pressure: A comparative study of various analytical capillary pressure formulations in matching laboratory results. Paper SPE 182469 Presented at the SPE Asia Pacific Oil & Gas Conference and Exhibition, Perth, Australia, 25-27 October, 2016.
Bennion, D. B., Bachu, S. Dependence on temperature, pressure, and salinity of the IFT and relative permeability displacement characteristics of CO2 injected in deep saline aquifers. Paper SPE 102138 Presented at the SPE Annual Technical Conference and Exhibition, San Antonio, Texas, USA, 24-27 September, 2006.
Bennion, D. B., Bachu, S. Correlations for the interfacial tension between supercritical phase CO2 and equilibrium brines at in-situ conditions. Paper SPE 114479 Presented at the SPE Annual Technical Conference and Exhibition, Denver, Colorado, USA, 21-24 September, 2008a.
Bennion, D. B., Bachu, S. Drainage and imbibition relative permeability relationships for supercritical CO2 /brine and H2S /brine systems in intergranular sandstone, carbonate, shale, and anhydrite rocks. SPE Reservoir Evaluation & Engineering, 2008b, 11(3): 487-496.
Bennion, D. B., Bachu, S. Drainage and imbibition CO2/brine relative permeability curves at reservoir conditions for carbonate formations. Paper SPE 134028 Presented at the SPE Annual Technical Conference and Exhibition, Florence, Italy, 19-22 September, 2010.
Berg, S., Oedai, S., Ott, H. Displacement and mass transfer between saturated and unsaturated CO2-brine systems in sandstone. International Journal of Greenhouse Gas Control, 2013, 12: 478-492.
Brooks, R. H., & Corey, A. T. Properties of porous media affecting fluid flow. Journal of the Irrigation and Drainage Division, 1966, 92(2): 61-88.
Brown, H. W. Capillary pressure investigations. Journal of Petroleum Technology, 1951, 3(3): 67-74.
Chierici, G. L. Novel relations for drainage and imbibition relative permeabilities. Society of Petroleum Engineers Journal, 24(3): 275-276, 1984.
Choi, J. W., Nicot, J. P., Hosseini, S. A., et al. CO2 recycling accounting and EOR operation scheduling to assist in storage capacity assessment at a U.S. Gulf Coast depleted reservoir. International Journal of Greenhouse Gas Control, 2013, 18: 474-484.
Christoffersen, K. R., Whitson, C. H. Gas/oil capillary pressure of chalk at elevated pressures. SPE Formation Evaluation, 1995, 10(3): 153-159.
Corey, A. T. The interrelation between gas and oil relative permeabilities. Producers Monthly, 1954, 19: 38-41.
Dai, Z., Zhang, Y., Bielicki, J., et al. Heterogeneity-assisted carbon dioxide storage in marine sediments. Applied Energy, 2018, 225: 876-883.
El-Maghraby, R. M., Blunt, M. J. Residual CO2 trapping in Indiana limestone. Environmental Science & Technology, 47(1): 227-233, 2013.
Falkowski, P., Scholes, R. J., Boyle, E. E. A., et al. The global carbon cycle: A test of our knowledge of Earth as a system. Science, 2000, 290(5490): 291-296.
Faramarzi-Palangar, M., Mirzaei-Paiaman, A. Identifying two-phase flow rock types in CO2-brine systems using TEM-function. Journal of Petroleum Science and Engineering, 2021, 205: 108818.
Faramarzi-Palangar, M., Mirzaei-Paiaman, A. Investigating dynamic rock quality in two-phase flow systems using TEM-function: A comparative study of different rock typing indices. Petroleum Research, 2021, 6(1): 16-25.
Faramarzi-Palangar, M., Sedaee, B., Niri, M. E. A further investigation on the application of critical pore size as an approach for reservoir rock typing. Journal of Energy Resources Technology, 2021a, 143(11): 112901.
Faramarzi-Palangar, M., Mirzaei-Paiaman, A., Ghoreishi, S. A., et al. Wettability of carbonate reservoir rocks: A comparative analysis. Applied Sciences, 2021b, 12(1): 131.
Feigl, A. Treatment of relative permeabilities for application in hydrocarbon reservoir simulation model. Nafta, 2011, 62(7-8): 233-243.
Gao, H., Yu, B., Duan, Y., et al. Fractal analysis of dimensionless capillary pressure function. International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer, 2014, 69: 26-33.
Gates, J. I., Lietz, W. T. Relative permeabilities of California cores by the capillary-pressure method. Paper Presented at the Spring Meeting of the Pacific Coast District, Division of Production, Los Angeles, California, May, 1950.
Gdanski, R., Fulton, D., Shen, C. Fracture-face-skin evolution during cleanup. SPE Production & Operations, 2009, 24(1): 22-34.
Gershenzon, N. I., Ritzi Jr, R. W., Dominic, D. F., et al. Comparison of CO2 trapping in highly heterogeneous reservoirs with Brooks-Corey and Van Genuchten type capillary pressure curves. Advances in Water Resources, 2016, 96: 225-236.
Goda, H. S., Behrenbruch, P. A universal formulation for the prediction of capillary pressure. Paper SPE 147078 Presented at the SPE Annual Technical Conference and Exhibition, Denver, Colorado, USA, 30 October-2 November, 2011.
Greder, H. N., Gallato, V., Cordelier, P., et al. Forty comparisons of mercury injection data with oil/water capillary pressure measurements by the porous plate technique. Paper SCA-9710 Presented at the Society of Core Analysis Symposium, Calgary, Alberta, Canada, 1997.
Hashemi, S. M. H., Monfaredi, K., Sedaee, B. An inclusive consistency check procedure for quality control methods of the black oil laboratory data. Journal of Petroleum Exploration and Production Technology, 2020, 10: 2153- 2173.
Honarpour, M., Koederitz, L. F., Harvey, A. H. Empirical equations for estimating two-phase relative permeability in consolidated rock. Journal of Petroleum Technology, 1982, 34(12): 2905-2908.
Honarpour, M., Mahmood, S. M. Relative-permeability measurements: An overview. Journal of Petroleum Technology, 1988, 40(8): 963-966.
Hopmans, J. W., Grismer, M. E., Chen, J., et al. Parameter estimation of two-fluid capillary pressure saturation and permeability functions. Cincinnati, National Risk Management Research Laboratory, Office of Research and Development, USEPA, 1998.
Ibrahim, M. N., Koederitz, L. F. Two-phase steady-state and unsteady-state relative permeability prediction models. Paper SPE 68065 Presented at the SPE Middle East Oil Show, Manama, Bahrain, 17-20 March, 2001.
Iglauer, S., Pentland, C. H., Busch, A. CO2 wettability of seal and reservoir rocks and the implications for carbon geo sequestration. Water Resources Research, 2015, 51(1): 729-774.
Imbus, S. W., Orr, F. M., Kuuskraa, V. A., et al. Critical issues in CO2 capture and storage: Findings of the SPE advanced technology workshop (ATW) on carbon sequestration. Paper SPE 102968 Presented at the SPE Annual Technical Conference and Exhibition, San Antonio, Texas, USA, 24-27 September, 2006.
Ioannidis, M. A., Chatzis, I. Network modelling of pore structure and transport properties of porous media. Chemical Engineering Science, 1993, 48(5): 951-972.
Jia, W., McPherson, B., Pan, F., et al. Impact of three-phase relative permeability and hysteresis models on forecasts of storage associated with CO2-EOR. Water Resources Research, 2018, 54(2): 1109-1126
Jing, X. D., Van Wunnik, J. N. M. A capillary pressure function for interpretation of core-scale displacement experiments. Paper SCA-9807 Presented at the Society of Core Analysts Symposium, the Hague, Netherlands, 14-16 September, 1998.
Johnson, A. Permeability averaged capillary data: A supplement to log analysis in field studies. Paper SPWLA-1987-EE Presented at the SPWLA 28th Annual Logging Symposium, London, England, 29 June-2 July, 1987.
Jones, S. C., Roszelle, W. O. Graphical techniques for determining relative permeability from displacement experiments. Journal of Petroleum Technology, 1978, 30(5): 807-817.
Kosugi, K. Lognormal distribution model for unsaturated soil hydraulic properties. Water Resources Research, 1996, 32(9): 2697-2703.
Lalanne, B., Rebelle, M. A review of alternative methods to classify rock-types from capillary pressure measure ments. Paper cp-395-00124 Presented at the International Petroleum Technology Conference, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia, 10-12 December, 2014.
Leverett, M. C., Lewis, W. B. Steady flow of gas-oil-water mixtures through unconsolidated sands. Transactions of the AIME, 1941, 142(1): 107-116.
Leverett, M. C. Capillary behavior in porous solids. Transactions of the AIME, 1941, 142(1): 152-169.
Li, B., Tchelepi, H. A., Benson, S. M. Influence of capillary-pressure models on CO2 solubility trapping. Advances in Water Resources, 2013, 62: 488-498.
Li, K., Horne, R. N. An experimental and analytical study of steam/water capillary pressure. SPE Reservoir Evaluation & Engineering, 2001, 4(6): 477-482.
Li, K., Horne, R. N. Comparison of methods to calculate relative permeability from capillary pressure in consolidated water-wet porous media. Water Resources Research, 2006, 42(6): W06405.
Li, K., Horne, R. N. Fractal characterization of the Geysers rock. Paper Presented at the Geothermal Resources Council Annual Meeting, Morelia, Mexico, 12-15 October, 2003.
Li, K. Generalized capillary pressure and relative permeability model inferred from fractal characterization of porous media. Paper SPE 89874 Presented at the SPE Annual Technical Conference and Exhibition, Houston, Texas, 26-29 September, 2004.
Li, K. More general capillary pressure and relative permeability models from fractal geometry. Journal of Contaminant Hydrology, 2010, 111(1-4): 13-24.
Liu, R., Liu, H., Li, X., et al. Calculation of oil and water relative permeability for extra low permeability reservoir. Paper SPE 131388 Presented at the International Oil and Gas Conference and Exhibition in China, Beijing, 8-10 June, 2010.
Lomeland, F., Ebeltoft, E. Versatile three-phase correlations for relative permeability and capillary pressure. Paper SCA2013-034 Presented at the International Symposium of the Society of Core Analysts, Napa Valley, California, USA, 16-19 September, 2013.
Lomeland, F., Ebeltoft, E., Thomas, W. H. A new versatile relative permeability correlation. Paper SCA-2005-112 Presented at the International Symposium of the Society of Core Analysts, Toronto, Canada, 21-25 August, 2005.
Maini, B., Coskuner, G., Jha, K. A comparison of steady-state and unsteady-state relative permeabilities of viscous oil and water in Ottawa sand. Journal of Canadian Petroleum Technology, 1990, 29(2): PETSOC-90-02-02.
Manceau, J. C., Ma, J., Li, R., et al. Two-phase flow properties of a sandstone rock for the CO2/water system: Coreflooding experiments, and focus on impacts of mineralogical changes. Water Resources Research, 2015, 51(4): 2885-2900.
Ma, S., Morrow, N. R. Relationships between porosity and permeability for porous rocks. Paper SCA-9610 Presented at the International Symposium of the Society of Core Analysts, Montpellier, France, 8-10 September, 1996.
Mirzaei-Paiaman, A., Faramarzi-Palangar, M., Djezzar, S., et al. A new approach to measure wettability by relative permeability measurements. Journal of Petroleum Science and Engineering, 2022, 208: 109191.
Moghadasi, L., Guadagnini, A., Inzoli, F., et al. Interpretation of two-phase relative permeability curves through multiple formulations and model quality criteria. Journal of Petroleum Science and Engineering, 2015, 135: 738-749.
Mualem, Y. A new model for predicting the hydraulic conductivity of unsaturated porous media. Water Resources Research, 1976, 12(3): 513-522.
Nasr, N. H. Integrating core and log data by using different saturation height functions (SHF). IRC, 2015.
Nazari Moghaddam, R., Jamiolahmady, M. Steady-state relative permeability measurements of tight and shale rocks considering capillary end effect. Transport in Porous Media, 2019, 128: 75-96.
Newsham, K. E., Rushing, J. A., Lasswell, P. M., et al. A comparative study of laboratory techniques for measuring capillary pressures in tight gas sands. Paper SPE 89866 Presented at the SPE Annual Technical Conference and Exhibition, Houston, Texas, 26-29 September, 2004.
Oostrom, M., White, M. D., Porse, S. L., et al. Comparison of relative permeability-saturation-capillary pressure models for simulation of reservoir CO2 injection. International Journal of Greenhouse Gas Control, 2016, 45: 70-85.
Pentland, C. H., El-Maghraby, R., Iglauer, S., et al. Measurements of the capillary trapping of super-critical carbon dioxide in Berea sandstone. Geophysical Research Letters, 2011, 38(6): L06401.
Pini, R., Krevor, S. C. M., Benson, S. M. Capillary pressure and heterogeneity for the CO2/water system in sandstone rocks at reservoir conditions. Advances in Water Resources, 2012, 38: 48-59.
Pini, R., Krevor, S., Krause, M., et al. Capillary heterogeneity in sandstone rocks during CO2/water core-flooding experiments. Energy Procedia, 2013, 37: 5473-5479.
Plug, W. J., Bruining, J. Capillary pressure for the sand-CO2-water system under various pressure conditions. Application to CO2 sequestration. Advances in Water Resources, 2007, 30(11): 2339-2353.
Purcell, W. R. Capillary pressures: Their measurement using mercury and the calculation of permeability therefrom. Journal of Petroleum Technology, 1949, 1(2): 39-48.
Raza, A., Gholami, R., Rezaee, R., et al. Significant aspects of carbon capture and storage-a review. Petroleum, 2019, 5(4): 335-340.
Ren, W., Li, G., Tian, S., et al. Comparison of capillary pressure-saturation models for gas-water systems in shale gas reservoirs. Paper SPE 182461 Presented at the SPE Asia Pacific Oil & Gas Conference and Exhibition, Perth, Australia, 25-27 October, 2016.
Safari, H., Faramarzi-Palangar, M., Hashemi, S. M. H., et al. A new approach to 3D saturation height modeling by coupling a capillary pressure model with pore throat size distribution. Natural Resources Research, 2022, 31(2): 1045-1059.
Sarwaruddin, M., Skauge, A., Torsaeter, O. Modeling of capillary pressure for heterogeneous reservoirs by a modified J-Function. Paper SCA-2001-35 Presented at the Society of Core Analysts Symposium, Edinburgh, Scotland, 16-19 September, 2001.
Shen, J. S. Automated steady state relative permeability measurement system. US4773254, 1988.
Shi, S., Belhaj, H., Bera, A. Capillary pressure and relative permeability correlations for transition zones of carbonate reservoirs. Journal of Petroleum Exploration and Production Technology, 2018, 8(3): 767-784.
Silin, D., Tomutsa, L., Benson, S. M., et al. Microtomography and pore-scale modeling of two-phase fluid distribution. Transport in Porous Media, 2011, 86: 495-515.
Skelt, C., Harrison, B. An integrated approach to saturation height analysis. Paper SPWLA-1995-NNN Presented at the SPWLA 36th Annual Logging Symposium, Paris, France, 26-29 June, 1995.
Thomeer, J. H. M. Introduction of a pore geometrical factor defined by the capillary pressure curve. Journal of Petroleum Technology, 1960, 12(3): 73-77.
Tokunaga, T. K., Wan, J., Jung, J. W., et al. Capillary pressure and saturation relations for supercritical CO2 and brine in sand: High-pressure Pc(Sw) controller/meter measurements and capillary scaling predictions. Water Resources Research, 2013, 49(8): 4566-4579.
Tsakiroglou, C. D., Theodoropoulou, M. A., Karoutsos, V. Nonequilibrium capillary pressure and relative permeability curves of porous media. AIChE Journal, 2003, 49(10): 2472-2486.
Van Genuchten, M. Th. A closed-form equation for predicting the hydraulic conductivity of unsaturated soils. Soil Science Society of America Journal, 1980, 44(5): 892-898.
Wang, S., Tokunaga, T. K. Capillary pressure-saturation relations for supercritical CO2 and brine in limestone/- dolomite sands: Implications for geologic carbon sequestration in carbonate reservoirs. Environmental Science & Technology, 2015, 49(12): 7208-7217.
Wang, X., Alvarado, V., Swoboda-Colberg, N., et al. Reactivity of dolomite in water-saturated supercritical carbon dioxide: Significance for carbon capture and storage and for enhanced oil and gas recovery. Energy Conversion and Management, 2013, 65: 564-573.
Wiltgen, N. A., Le Calvez, J., Owen, K. Methods of saturation modeling using capillary pressure averaging and pseudos. Paper SPWLA-2003-W Presented at the SPWLA 44th Annual Logging Symposium, Galveston, Texas, 22-25 June, 2003.
Sun, X., Mohanty, K. K. Estimation of flow functions during drainage using genetic algorithm. Paper presented at the SPE Annual Technical Conference and Exhibition, Denver, Colorado, 5-8 October, 2003.
Xu, W., Luo, P., Sun, L., et al. A prediction model of the capillary pressure J-function. PLoS ONE, 2016, 11(9): e0162123.
Yu, P., Archer, R. A fractal gas-water relative permeability model in geothermal reservoirs, in Proceedings, 44th Workshop on Geothermal Reservoir Engineering, Stanford University, Stanford, California, pp. 1-13, 2019.
Zhang, Y., Yang, D. Simultaneous estimation of relative permeability and capillary pressure for tight formations using ensemble-based history matching method. Computers & Fluids, 2013, 71: 446-460.
Refbacks
- There are currently no refbacks.
Copyright (c) 2025 The Author(s)
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.